Matthew 26:31-35
Rev. Jerry Hoek

I don’t remember if I told you this before or not, but when I was in college I took a physical education class in handball. At the end of the class, there was a tournament and I was scheduled to play my friend Rick. Rick was a far better athlete than I was so I played very hard and surprisingly found myself well ahead of him – within a few points of actually winning. I felt sorry for him though and so eased way up, confident that I would win the last few points and go on in the tournament. Well, you can imagine what happened. I got overconfident, he found his confidence and I ended up losing. I thought I would easily beat him but I lost and was eliminated.
In Matthew 26:31-35, we see another case where overconfidence leads to a person’s downfall. The disciples claimed that they would be able to endure whatever challenges that were before them. The problem was that they were relying on themselves for their confidence rather than on Jesus. If we are confident only in ourselves, we are bound to fail. Let’s read Matthew 26:31-35.
I. Jesus’ Prediction
II. Peter’s Protest
III. How Strong (or Weak) Are We?
I. In verse 31, Jesus says, “This very night you will all fall away on account of me.”
Jesus said this as He and the disciples were making their way to the Garden of Gethsemane. The disciples were likely feeling quite good and secure again. Jesus had reassured them that they would be with him again after Jesus’ announcement that one of them would betray him. But again Jesus shatters their sense of peace with a startling statement.
Jesus says that they will fall away or abandon Him because of Jesus. They will be terribly frightened and confused by Jesus’ arrest. Their serious weakness will cause them to desert Jesus. Not only this, but they will all fall away. While only one will betray him, all of them will desert Jesus.
And the final blow comes in the words, “this very night.” This is not something that will happen on down the road sometime. This is something that will occur within the next few hours.
As proof of this, He points to a prophecy from Zechariah in the Old Testament. “I will strike the shepherd, and the sheep of the flock will be scattered.” Jesus means that God is the One who will strike down the shepherd. God will act through the enemies of Jesus and will allow His own Son to be killed. Once again, we see that Jesus’ death is not the result of someone’s evil plot. Jesus’ death is the result of God’s plan and deliberate activity.
And when God uses Jesus’ enemies to strike down His Son, the disciples who were following Jesus like sheep follow a shepherd, will all scatter. The shepherd is vital for the care and keeping of the sheep. If the shepherd is gone, the sheep become victims to predators. They also have no idea where to go or what they are to do. The results were chaos as the sheep scattered.
When Jesus is arrested and taken away, they all will flee for their lives. They will not want to be associated with Jesus at that time. We will look at how the disciples responded to this in just a moment.
But before they could respond, Jesus gives them hope for the future as well. They will leave Jesus, but Jesus assures them that they will meet again in Galilee. This must have greatly reassured the disciples after Jesus’ death and resurrection. They likely looked back on this prediction and took comfort in the fact that they would be reunited with Jesus. Even though they abandoned Jesus, He said He wouldn’t abandon them. That is a beautiful picture of God’s grace shown in Jesus.
In his book Healing Grace, David Seamands relates an old good news-bad news story. A farmer who had experienced several bad years went to see the manager of his bank and said, “I’ve got some good news and some bad news to tell you. Which would you like to hear first?” The banker replied, “Why don’t you give me the bad news first and get it over with.”
The farmer said, “Ok. With the bad drought and inflation and all, I won’t be able to pay anything on my mortgage this year, either on the principle or the interest.” The banker said, “Well, that is pretty bad.”
The farmer continued, “It gets worse. I also won’t be able to pay anything on the loan for the machinery I bought, not the principle or interest.” The banker said, “Wow! That is bad!”
The farmer continued again, “It’s worse than that. You remember I also borrowed to buy seeds and fertilizer and other supplies. Well, I can’t pay anything on that either – principle or interest.” The banker said, “That’s awful – and that’s enough. Tell me what the good news is!”
The farmer said, “The good news is that I intend to keep on doing business with you.” David Seamands comments: “There’s some rather profound theology in that story, provided we reverse the subjects. The good news of the Gospel is that in spite of our total moral bankruptcy, God keeps on doing business with us.” The disciples didn’t deserve it, yet Jesus will accept them and work with them. Jesus’ grace would be with them as he continued to shape them into the founders of His church.
You see, Jesus is doing more than just predicting what will happen. Jesus is reassuring them that no matter what will happen, He will be there with them. After the stark description of their desertion comes the offer of hope and Christ’s love. The problem was that the disciples didn’t think that they would need it.
II. In verses 33-35, Peter Protests what Jesus has just said.
Peter says, “Even if all fall away on account of you, I never will.” Now we must be careful that we give Peter some credit in his response. It is easy for us knowing what happens next to scorn Peter for his response. However, Peter really did mean what he said. He truly believed he would stand by Jesus with unswerving loyalty.
However, there are 3 things about Peter’s statement that show his error. First, he responded with disbelief regarding what Jesus had said. Peter told Jesus that what Jesus had just said wasn’t true. In effect, Peter told Jesus: “You don’t know what you’re talking about.”
Second, he also was guilty of putting the other disciples down. He pointed to himself and said that in spite of what the others might do, HE would never leave Jesus. One author speculates on what Peter may have been thinking: [S-11] “Matthew, the former publican, might stoop down to that low level of abandoning his Master in his hour of affliction. My former fishing partners might also conceivably fall into that same trap. In fact, I wouldn’t even put it past my own brother Andrew… BUT NOT I.”
Peter was also guilty of having far too much pride. He was guilty of overconfidence and conceit. He was not acting in humility as Jesus had taught him. Peter’s response shows that his trust is exclusively in himself.
Jesus’ tries to help Peter see just how vulnerable he is: “I tell you the truth, this very night, before the rooster crows, you will disown me three times.” Jesus solemnly declares: “I tell you the truth.” This meant that what followed was very true and very serious.
Peter will not only desert Jesus, he will deny or disown him. And this will happen in the next few hours. Within just a few hours, Peter will deny that he had ever known Jesus. Jesus is absolutely positive that Peter will deny him.
Jesus likely makes this specific prediction so that when it happened, Peter would be able to clearly recognize it. It is love that motivates Jesus to make this pointed prediction. If Peter can recognize his falling, he will be able to repent of it.
But even this very specific prediction doesn’t faze Peter. Peter says, “Even if I have to die with you, I will never disown you.” He will certainly never desert Jesus if he is willing to die with him. He truly believes his commitment is, as one put it, “death-deep.”
This may explain why Peter started to fight when Jesus was arrested. He likely wanted to prove that he was ready to die for Jesus. But the problem was that his faith was in the wrong person.
Peter had no basis to make his bold claims except his own desire. Peter’s faith was in himself, his own desire to be faithful, but that would simply not be enough to save him from falling.
Also when I was in college, I went on a camping trip with a good friend of mine on the Au Sable River in northern Michigan. We decided to “rough it,” bringing little food and the simplest of provisions. We tried to get drinking water through a special device and tried fishing for our food.
This was virtually a disaster from the beginning and yet we survived. At one point we were fishing in a river and I had caught a small to average sized trout and I was feeling pretty good.
I threw my line out in the water again but didn’t have it quite where I wanted it and so I repositioned my foot on a tree that was hanging out over the water. I rested it there for a few seconds and then shifted a bit and heard the sound of cracking wood and soon I found myself in the cold water.
I was feeling very confident but my faith was misplaced and I ended up falling. Peter made a very bold claim, but he had nothing to back it up with.
And Matthew reports that all the other disciples joined him in stating their loyalty as well. They are confident that their loyalty to Christ is strong enough to make them stand by Jesus. They were relying as well on their own abilities and strengths. They were thinking, “Jesus may think I’m not strong enough, but I’ll prove Him wrong. I will not allow myself to fall away.”
At that Jesus has nothing more to say. Jesus already knows what is going to happen and there is no further point in debating whether or not they will desert Him. As the events unfold, what Jesus said will be proved to be true. Then the disciples will learn that they cannot rely on themselves to serve Christ. They need to have the power of Christ within them if they are going to be able to stand with Christ.
Self-confidence is simply overconfidence when it comes to the Christian life. If we are relying on ourselves, we are doomed to fall. We are placing our trust in the wrong person. Our source of strength for our Christian lives must be Jesus!
III. Finally, let’s ask: How Can We Remain Loyal Today?
There are things in our lives that will test our loyalty to Christ. Non-Christian friends may ridicule us for our beliefs and Christian involvement. We may be tempted to down-play our relationship to Christ. Or we may even be tempted in some way disown Christ in that area.
Our work or careers may not be compatible with our relationship with Christ. Our jobs may require that we do things that are contrary to what Christ has commanded us to do. And then we are faced with a choice of either being loyal to Christ or risking our jobs and careers.
Our possessions can also cause us to question our loyalty to Christ. Are we really willing to give up all we have to follow Christ? If we lose all we have, would we remain faithful to Christ or would we blame him for the hardship that would cause?
Our personal choices may have the net result of testing our loyalty to Christ. Do we do things that we want to do that we know Christ does not approve of? It is tempting to have ourselves as the most important person in our lives. There are many things that could cause us to stumble in our lives.
The point we need to see in these verses is that we cannot rely on ourselves. The tendency is for us to think that we are strong and good people. We would never disown or renounce our faith in Christ. If someone were to put a gun to us and say, “Renounce Christ or die,” we would say, “shoot me.”
Now while that kind of resolve is admirable, we have to make sure that it is rooted in the right person. If we rely on our own strength, we will be bitterly disappointed. We are simply too weak, too full of sin to be able to withstand the challenges to our faith.
You may have heard the story of the patient who went to a psychiatrist to find help for his depression. The doctor listened to his complaints and prescribed some medication. He concluded with this suggestion: “Go and see a performance by the clown, Grock. He’s sure to cheer you up.” However, the patient replied, “Alas! I am Grock!” If we think that simply by our own resolve and strength we will remain faithful to Christ no matter what, we are sadly mistaken.
Now please understand that I’m not saying that we don’t need to have faith. We do need to have a lot of strong faith. But we must be certain that it is faith that is placed firmly and exclusively in Christ, not ourselves. There is a monumental difference between saying that my faith in myself is strong and my faith in Christ is strong.
How can we focus our faith exclusively on Christ. First, we need to admit our sins and our failures. We must admit that on our own, we cannot remain faithful to Christ. We, no matter how strong we think we may be, are not strong enough. That is the first lesson these verses teach us.
The second lesson is this: Christ will forgive and restore us even if we fail. Jesus did this when He promised to meet the disciples in Galilee. Even though they will desert Him, He will not desert them. There is strong and ringing reassurance of forgiveness from Christ.

Tom Watson, Sr., the founder of IBM knew the importance of forgiving others. A promising junior executive was involved in a risky venture for the company and lost over $10 million. When Watson called the nervous executive into his office, the young man blurted out, “I guess you want my resignation!” Watson said, “You can’t be serious. We’ve just spent $10 million educating you!” God will forgive us when we fail and fall.
This week you will likely face things which will test your loyalty to Christ. Let’s not become overconfident and just assume that our own strength will help us overcome. Instead, let’s admit that we cannot remain faithful on our own.
Secondly, let’s ask God for His help in overcoming and remaining strong. Finally, when we fail and fall, trust that God, in His grace , will be there to pick you up and go with you again. On whom will you place your faith and trust as you walk with God this week?

As I traveled with a Christian friend in Rishikesh, India, he pointed to a row of beggars lined up near a bridge across the River Ganges and explained why the Hindu religion will never help such as them. They are living out the results of karma. If they are poor lepers or maimed in this life it is because they sinned in a past life. To help them would only fate them to suffer again until they got it right. Contrast this with the ministry of Christ, who healed the lepers, made the lame to walk and the blind to see. We may not have the miraculous powers Christ had, but we should have his heart, and never accept fatalistically that some suffering is meant to be. We should be moved with compassion, as was our Lord, and we should do what we can to help, to aid and comfort. Disciples must serve and be served because Christ will not let us ignore the need.



No comments »